Bishop acknowledged Gill has the temperament and cricketing skill, but noted that tactical maturity and decision-making under pressure still need time to develop. He pointed out that senior players Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli will be crucial in guiding Gill through this phase.
The comments come amid mixed reactions to some of Gill’s aggressive captaincy moves — especially the decision to enforce a follow-on against West Indies in the second Test, which drew criticism when the opposition mounted a fightback. Gill later defended the call, saying the conditions and match situation warranted bold decisions.
Gill, 26, has had a strong start as captain — scoring centuries, leading from the front, and securing India’s first Test series win under his leadership against the West Indies. But Bishop’s critique underscores that leadership at the international level is a gradual process, and consistent performance over seasons will define Gill’s legacy.
As Gill shoulders multiple roles (Test & ODI captain), the cricketing world watches whether he can refine his on-field tactics and responses under mounting scrutiny. The support of senior teammates and his own adaptability will likely influence how quickly he evolves.